Intention: The starting point of intelligent Web3 interaction
Looking forward to the future of intelligent interaction in Web3, whether it is account abstraction, chain abstraction, or intent, Web3 is finally paying attention to user experience, and the dawn of intelligent interaction is about to illuminate the dark forest.Original Author: Xuan Rui
Content Source: AC Capital Research
This article will explore the concept of intent through Anoma and TG Bot, tracing the paradigm shift of AI behind intent, deeply understanding the evolution of the concept of intent, interaction paradigms, current status, trends, and finally looking forward to the challenges and future of intelligent Web3 interaction.
Summary (TL;DR)
(1) Understanding Intent: Top-Down Anoma vs. Bottom-Up TG Bot
(2) Deep Dive into Intent: AI is the New UI: Complex Commands vs. Simple Intent
(3) Navigating Intent: The Evolution of the Concept of Intent, Interaction Paradigms, Current Status, Trends
(4) Guiding Intent: Challenges and Outlook for Intelligent Web3 Interaction
In June, Paradigm published an article titled "Intent-Based Architectures and Their Risks," which brought the concept of Intent to the public for the first time. The development of protocols and infrastructure related to intent has been rapid, becoming an unavoidable topic in the crypto world during the ETHCC conference in July.
Intent is not a new concept. As Mindao, the founder of DForce, stated: the trend in the crypto space has always been to abstract and automate operations to the extreme. From aggregators, CEX, contract wallets, to cross-chain DeFi, all these efforts are aimed at achieving this. There are also Chainlink and the recent automated middleware, as well as the recent Telegram bot.
However, intent brings new changes. In the past, the focus was on product interaction, while in the AGI era, the focus shifts to human-computer interaction. AI/LLM (Large Language Models) hold more potential to enhance crypto interactions.
Top-Down Anoma vs. Bottom-Up Unibot
In the past six months, protocols, projects, and infrastructures related to intent have been booming. Here, we do not intend to explain concepts in detail but rather present two excellent examples to provide insight.
Although there are many projects related to intent, the most prominent is the Anoma Foundation, which completed its third round of financing of $25 million at the end of May 2023. In the context of severe homogenization in Layer 1, the Anoma Foundation, with its intent-centric architecture Anoma (Dapp full-stack architecture) and Namada (privacy Layer 1), has raised a total of $57.8 million in three rounds of funding, ranking seventh in financing amounts for Layer 1/Layer 2 that have not yet issued tokens.
Looking back at Anoma's public speech at EthCC, founder Adrian Brink stated that the magic of Anoma lies in the fact that all interactions begin with intent. Users express their intent, which is processed through the Black-box Architecture (Anoma's black box architecture, also known as Magic Happens). The magic box implements the core transaction process based on intent interaction:
User Interaction: Users can send transparent, private, or protected intents to Anoma's black box architecture (intent gossip Layer).
Intent Collection and Matching: The solver in Anoma's black box architecture collects intents and performs balancing state transitions to match counterparties.
Transaction Processing: Matched transactions are submitted to the encrypted mempool, and validators send the blocks packaged by proposers to the execution layer, completing execution and verifying validity, ultimately updating the state root.
Source: https://twitter.com/Delphi_Digital/status/1696626180752056764
Behind this new form of interaction, the Anoma team has identified the underlying pain points of blockchain protocols. They reviewed that since the first generation of Bitcoin's scriptable settlement, the architectural limitations of the second generation of Ethereum's programmable settlement have led to the current application protocols having at least one Web2 component, making it impossible to achieve counterparty discovery and resolution. They stated that the intent-centric Anoma architecture is the third generation of Dapp architecture in the evolution of blockchain protocols, allowing users to define the desired outcome state, achieving efficient and customizable privacy transactions at the intent level. The intent-centric Dapp architecture is ushering in a new era.
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdYwfW6tMJ8
With high financing and a new technological architecture, Anoma is currently built by a multidisciplinary team of 37 members from the Heliax development team. Although the progress of the Heliax development team has been slow over the past two years, a complete innovation ecosystem has been formed:
Anoma: A general Dapp architecture centered on intent, which can be modularly deployed to L1, L1.5, and L2, embedding modular components into various EVM frameworks for invocation;
Namada: The privacy settlement Layer 1 of the Anoma ecosystem, using a PoS mechanism for asset-agnostic inter-chain privacy, which will be compatible with Ethereum and IBC chains in the future;
AnomaVM: Simplifying DApp application development on Anoma, using Juvix (an intent-centric programming language) and VampIR (a circuit programming language);
Typhon: An improved consensus based on Cosmos's Tendermint;
Taiga: Providing a unified execution environment for composable privacy, defining three types of intent: transparent intent, shielded intent, and private intent.
Source: https://heliax.dev/#projects
Although many institutions such as CMCC Global, Electric Capital, and Delphi Digital are enthusiastically promoting Anoma and expressing that the intent-centric architecture has unlimited potential for the future, the top-down Anoma has only laid a good technical foundation without visible exciting applications. On the other hand, TG Bot has opened up the imagination of intent in segmented scenarios with on-chain automated trading tools.
Unibot is a Telegram-based trading bot (TG Bot) that allows users to conduct automated DEX trading through Telegram, providing features such as sniper buying, follow trading, DEX limit orders, privacy, and MEV resistance. Unibot replaces the cumbersome interactions of Uniswap with intent, offering a convenient DeFi interaction experience. Unibot has also spawned a batch of TG Bot clones, with the current total market capitalization of the TG Bot track approaching $200 million.
Top-down Anoma is innovation, while bottom-up TG Bot is transformation; top-down Anoma starts from the intent-based underlying architecture, but the team's progress is slow; TG Bot, while bringing users a new on-chain interaction interface, is not intelligent and has many security risks.
Despite their different paths, both aim for the same goal—simplifying user interaction experience and introducing a new programmable, customizable user interaction interface—User Intent Layer, allowing users to bypass complex on-chain interactions and define transaction states based on user intent.
AI is the New UI: Command Interaction vs. Intent Interaction
The two use cases above provide a basic understanding of intent. Next, it is time to explore the underlying changes brought by AI to the crypto world—the change in user interaction interfaces. The AI paradigm is introducing a third user interface paradigm in computer history, shifting towards a new interaction mechanism where users tell computers what they want rather than how to do it.
Paradigm One: Batch Processing.
Paradigm Two: Command-Based Interaction Design.
Paradigm Three: Intent-Based Outcome Specification.
Historically, every revolution in interaction patterns has led to entirely new business models. Generative AI based on LLM has brought disruptive changes to human-computer interaction, directly transforming the original human-computer interaction with various software UIs into interaction with a ChatGPT chat window. This is an unprecedented interaction experience, and LLM + crypto brings a new proposition for intent-based interaction in the crypto world. LLM will also make blockchain interactions potentially smarter by discovering and describing user intents.
The Evolution of the Concept of Intent, Interaction Paradigms, Current Status, Trends
After deeply understanding the AI intelligence trend behind intent, we further explore the evolution of the concept of intent. Intent is not a new concept; it has existed since the Web2 era. With the rise of search engines like Google, users can input intents, and search engines provide relevant search results to satisfy those intents.
With the emergence of e-commerce platforms like Amazon and eBay, the intent-based architecture underwent significant changes. Users can now express their intent to purchase products, while the platform handles logistics. In early 2017, Gartner published a report titled "Innovation Insight: Intent-Based Networking Systems," formally introducing the concept of Intent-based Networking. The key to intent-based networking is presenting users with an interface where they only need to express what they want, while the platform handles the business details.
Intent-based networking is a trend in the automation and intelligence development of networks in the Web2 era. Andrew Lerner, Vice President of Research at Gartner, pointed out in 2017 that intent-based networking would be the next milestone in the field of networking.
Source: https://www.gartner.com/en/documents/3599617
In the evolution from Web2 to Web3, the concept of intent in Web3 is not very clear, but there are some consensus points:
The definition provided by Paradigm: Intent is a set of declarative constraints that allow users to delegate transaction creation to a specialized network of third-party participants while retaining full control over the process.
The definition provided by the intent-based underlying Dapp architecture Anoma: Intent is a message sent by the user to express custom preferences. Intent is a constraint that defines what the user system can do, rather than a specific execution path.
The definition provided by the intent-based transaction infrastructure Propellerheads: Intent is part of a transaction that requires assistance from others, simplifying complex transactions by outsourcing the difficult parts to third parties.
In real use cases of intent-based transactions in Web3, users create intents off-chain, outsourcing them to Solvers (decoders) off-chain, encapsulating the complexity of blockchain interactions for the decoders while retaining full control over the process on-chain, thus lowering the threshold for on-chain interactions.
Source: https://www.brink.trade/blog/powerful-intents-part-1
Intent also brings the LLM architectural concept—intent-centric—an architecture centered on user intent. Currently, protocols and infrastructures related to intent-centric are embedded in the interaction layer between users and crypto, leveraging LLM to provide a better on-chain interaction experience.
LLM + Crypto brings a new human-computer interaction paradigm, directly converting user intents into smart contract calls. Users only need to express intents like using Apple's Siri, while robots/Ai Agents/third-party decoders help complete complex on-chain operations. In the future, intelligent Web3 interactions based on intent have the potential to greatly reduce the complexity of user on-chain interactions.
AI is the New UI. More and more Web3 projects are exploring the magic of intent, whether it is intent-based Dapps or intent-based underlying architectures, all releasing the potential of intent from different angles. We attempt to organize this rapidly developing field and categorize it into four major categories from the perspective of interaction, tracking the latest status and trends:
Infrastructure: (Intent-Centric Intent Architecture Layer)
DappOS: The first intent-centric Web3 operating protocol, building a middle layer between users and public chains, cross-chain bridges, and other crypto infrastructures, allowing Web3 users to interact with products seamlessly and unconsciously. Recently, DappOS released its V2 version;
Flash 2.0 SUAVE: SUAVE is a standalone plug-and-play modular MEV full-chain ordering layer. Preferences (the core concept of SUAVE) are similar to the concept of Intent, both providing ordinary users with a way to customize transactions, ultimately helping users achieve optimal execution. Flashbots plans to launch SUAVE Centauri in Q4 2023;
Anoma: A general Dapp architecture centered on intent, which can be modularly deployed to L1, L1.5, and L2, embedding modular components into various EVM frameworks for invocation. The latest development in the Anoma ecosystem is that Anoma's privacy settlement Layer 1—Namada—is about to launch the v0.22.0 testnet;
Cow Protocol: CoW Protocol builds an underlying settlement network for traders and decoders, and in July released the Cow Hooks, a new intent system for custom DeFi operations. CoW Protocol's latest data in August processed a total trading volume of $1.05 billion and generated $5.3 million in profits.
Supporting Facilities: (Supporting infrastructures related to intent and account abstraction wallets)
ERC 4337: The User Operation of ERC 4337 represents the user's intent, including the tokens for paying gas, payment choices, and login methods, replacing the current transaction memory pool, thus achieving account abstraction and improving wallet interaction experience.
Supporting infrastructures related to account abstraction: bundler infrastructures (StackUp, Blocknative, Alchemy Rundler, AA-Bundler, infinitism Bundler), wallet SDKs (Safe, ZeroDev, Biconomy);
Supporting infrastructures related to intent: Juvix (intent-based programming language), Seaport (open-source NFT trading protocol), Gelato (Web3 automated execution layer providing automation services for smart contracts), okcontract (low-level intent automation tool), Delegatable (smart contract authorization proxy tool), Hyper Oracle (off-chain automation service), symmio (intent-based on-chain derivatives trading framework).
Enterprise Applications: (Integrating intent infrastructure for Dapps, API, modular intent layers, specific domain decoders)
Transaction Decoder API: PropelleHeads;
Intent API: EnsoFinance;
Intent Transaction Infrastructure: Bob the Solver, Brink;
Composable Intent Tools: Essential.
Consumer Applications: (Intelligent interfaces for user interaction such as Wallets, Dex, Web3 Ai Agents, intelligent search engines)
Wallets: Safe, Bitconomy, Argent, Ambire, Sequence, Versa, A3S Protocol;
Dex: CowSwap, Paraswap, Uniswap, 1inch, BananaHq, basedmarkets;
Intelligent Frontends: Unibot, Dora, Web3 Analytics, kaito.ai.
The intent-based architecture, supporting facilities, and enterprise applications (listed here without expansion due to space constraints) attempt to solve the underlying challenges of implementing intent. However, infrastructure cannot be built overnight; the trend of intent consumer application layers is what truly excites. The evolution of interaction entry points such as wallets and Dex shows the potential for intelligent interaction. Wallet intelligence: ERC-4337 introduces a new (UserOps) user intent layer, where users express intent, and then the bundler converts these intents into executable signed transactions. In recent months, the number of ERC 4337 users has significantly increased, with ZeroDev, Biconomy, and Safe modular smart accounts being the most motivated to promote AA + intent. AA + intent has the potential to usher in the arrival of wallet intelligence (SCW).
The transformation of DEX architecture: Intent-Based Trading aims to improve capital efficiency and user interaction experience. CoW Hooks connects complex actions such as trading, bridging, staking, and depositing. UniswapX already allows users to sign intents for off-chain matching and on-chain settlement. Similar to BananaHq, Brink, and basedmarkets, more and more intent-based DEXs are emerging, and a new Intent-based RFQ narrative (SYMMIO) is unfolding. As more DEXs and aggregators shift towards intent-based architecture, the DEX landscape is undergoing significant changes.
Source: https://twitter.com/BananaHQio/status/1694013407929020740
Intelligent interaction entry points: Similar to how TG Bot transforms the Web3 front-end interaction interface, interaction entry points focus on understanding user intents and systematically converting them into automated, actionable tasks. Not only trading bots like TG Bot, but also Web3 Ai Agents and Web3 intelligent search engines are making Web3 interactions more intelligent.
Source: https://twitter.com/awasunyin/status/169540582237605496
Challenges and Outlook for Intelligent Web3 Interaction
In the past, the interaction experience of Web3 products indeed hindered widespread adoption, and the on-chain wealth creation effect masked many product issues. Now, liquidity and user attention are scattered, and on-chain liquidity is scarce.
At the ETHCC conference in July, developers extensively discussed the future of intent-centric interactions and how to help users complete DAPP interactions more intelligently in Web3. However, the application of intent-centric concepts still faces many challenges:
Lack of programming languages related to intent (similar to Juvix)
Lack of suitable intent architectures (similar to Anoma)
Lack of specific domain decoders (similar to Bob The Solver)
Centralized and closed intent implementations (similar to CowSwap)
Lack of front-end intent recognition decoders (similar to Unibot)
Lack of composable intent implementations (similar to Brink)
Intent security risks (as mentioned in the Paradigm article)
There are challenges but also hope. With the emergence of intent-centric protocols, Web3 has the potential to evolve into a more user-friendly intelligent interaction interface, allowing users to interact seamlessly with mainstream applications like Uniswap, Blur, and AAVE, making interactions as simple as hailing a ride with Uber. This is the real opportunity for Web3 Dapps to surpass Web2 in user experience. More importantly, combined with the visions for the future of intent-centric interactions from Anoma, Flashbots SUAVE, and DappOS, on-chain interactions in Web3 will also become more intelligent, customizable, and fair. At the same time, placing the power back in the hands of users with intent-centric approaches allows ordinary users to empower third-party bots/decoders to complete customized transactions (fees, slippage, privacy, cross-chain, MEV, or other intents). In the future, users will no longer be passive participants on-chain or victims of MEV Searchers and Validators, but the true captains of on-chain activities. Looking forward to the future of intelligent Web3 interaction, whether it is account abstraction, chain abstraction, or intent, Web3 is finally caring about user experience, and the dawn of intelligent interaction is about to illuminate the dark forest.
Acknowledgments
Special thanks to Web3 Analytics, Crypto V, Haotian, Chen Jian Jason, Luke, Grace Deng, SixSix.eth, POOR DAO, #017, armonio.eth, Kiwibig.eth for their valuable discussions, opinions, and feedback on this article.
References
https://twitter.com/mindaoyang/status/1696819223073571016
https://twitter.com/Delphi_Digital/status/1696626118164652295
https://twitter.com/awasunyin/status/169540582237605496
https://twitter.com/0xren_cf/status/1664320654819180564
https://twitter.com/LukeWasm/status/1691434740635873280
https://twitter.com/DodoResearch/status/1694652157830836640
https://ethglobal.com/showcase/bob-the-solver-yxtgp
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdYwfW6tMJ8\&t=85s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0nFyq9DDPw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMqaCGxSRQY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DIvHVvjwhAs\&t=22s
https://medium.com/banana-sdk/intent-is-all-you-need-part-1-1c5c11ee3b6f
https://medium.com/alliancedao/intents-are-just-7deaeb4336be
https://mirror.xyz/sevenxventures.eth/fknoBf3zOoBf55zNFBpMQAIat6iCT9tvrN2AY1j4Sv4
https://dba.mirror.xyz/NTg5FSq1oYiLKJrKBOsOkyeiNUPobvZUrLBGceagg
https://www.propellerheads.xyz/blog/intents-and-where-to-find-them
https://www.propellerheads.xyz/blog/blockchain-and-llms
https://www.paradigm.xyz/2023/06/intents
https://www.nngroup.com/articles/ai-paradigm/
https://aigc.phodal.com/llm-arch-user-intent-oriented-design.html
https://gracedeng.substack.com/p/decoding-intents-revolutionizing
https://thedefisaint.substack.com/p/intent-centric-a-narrative-worth
https://writings.fetcch.xyz/how-to-think-about-cross-chain-cowswap
https://www.brink.trade/blog/powerful-intents-part-1
https://blog.essential.builders/introducing-essential/
https://www.propellerheads.xyz/blog/intents-and-where-to-find-them
https://writings.flashbots.net/the-future-of-mev-is-suave/
https://www.blocknative.com/blog/ethcc-understanding-4337
https://writings.flashbots.net/mevm-suave-centauri-and-beyond
https://ethresear.ch/t/how-can-we-decentralize-intents/16456
https://www.gartner.com/en/documents/3599617
